THE MATCHMAKER
Quaint Irish Island Surrounded by Verbal Sewage
What You Need To Know
With the current popularity of things Irish, from the flashy footwork of RIVERDANCE to the ever-expanding reach of Celtic music into North American culture, a witty romantic comedy set in the Emerald Isle would seem to be a shoo-in for a mass-audience hit. Alas, THE MATCHMAKER has blown its opportunity for wide appeal with a non-stop flow of foul language which the filmmakers erroneously equate with sophistication. Without the verbal affronts, the film could easily have earned a PG rating and a much bigger audience.
Marcy (Janeane Garofalo) is an overworked aide to slippery Massachusetts Senator John McGlory, who is on the verge of losing a re-election bid. Because he has lost credibility with the voters by taking conflicting political positions, his acid-tongued advisor (Denis Leary) comes up with a desperate, eleventh hour scheme to recover some legitimacy: he wants to uncover the Senator’s ancestral roots in Ireland (or manufacture them, if necessary), and then wave them before a skeptical electorate, which happens to contain a large contingent of Irish voters.
A very unenthusiastic Marcy is dispatched post-haste across numerous time and culture zones to the tiny village of Ballinagra, which clings tenuously to its rugged coastline, not to mention the Twentieth Century. Wouldn’t you know, she arrives just at the beginning of the town’s Matchmaking Festival, an annual bash which jams every hotel and inn with tourists and turns every pub into a giant singles’ bar. (This event actually occurs every September in one of Ireland’s west coast villages.) Reigning over the festivities like Santa Claus at Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade is the country’s premier matchmaker, Dermot (Milo O’Shea), who immediately identifies Marcy as his greatest challenge
And, a challenge she is: edgy, thoroughly urbanized, frazzled because her cell phone and modem won’t work, cynical about the Senator’s half-baked plan which has landed her in the middle of nowhere, and completely unimpressed by the quaint surroundings and boorish men inhabiting them. One of the most uninspiring is Sean (David O’Hara), who approaches her with all of the finesse of an O’Sherman tank, but eventually, with Dermot’s conniving help, lands the assignment of tour guide for some of her necessary visitations.
It doesn’t take doctorate in English literature to figure out where this story will go, and so, ideally, getting there should be more than half the fun. Alas, the MATCHMAKER doesn’t deliver on its fish-out-of-water premise-which is in fact contrived nearly to the breaking point. (Do any voters, Irish-American or otherwise, really give a rip about a candidate’s family tree?)
Yes, Janeane Garofalo is fitfully funny, especially as she marches through one tavern after another proclaiming her search for McGlory relatives and fervently declaring that, by the way, she isn’t looking for a husband. However, just when her part-the-clouds smile begins to win you over, out comes another round of verbal sewage, matched with equal fervor by the townspeople around her.
Moreover, when it comes time to get to the inevitable romance with the still-married, but estranged Sean, there is precious little motivation for her transformation from disdain to come-hither looks. She and he also indulge in an impromptu and ridiculously premature romp in bed, which technically is adultery since Sean is still married to another woman during the romp. This is but another depiction of a fantasy relationship rocketing from clever repartee to sex and then supposedly generating intense longing thereafter. In the real world of long-term commitments, this couple has about as much a chance of forging a lasting partnership as two felines in a Boston alley. Whatever happened to intelligent conversation and acts of kindness (let alone spiritual compatibility) as the basis for emotional involvement?
To her credit, Marcy demonstrates some character in the film’s third act, as she challenges the sleazy tactics of the Senator and his abusive campaign manager and finally dumps both of them. The plea for honesty is nice, but there isn’t much of a moral quandary in her decision. In addition, one would have to have a heart of concrete not to appreciate the lilting music and the rugged beauty of the Irish coastline, especially the Isle of Innis Mor, where the remains of a huge fort are perched 300 feet above the churning sea. However, this is not enough to offset 96 minutes of jarring language and an underwhelming storyline.
Hot tip: this film could be quite enjoyable in a few months as an in-flight movie (especially if the plane is bound for Ireland), since the language would have to be cleaned up for general (ie. normal) audiences.