WATER FOR ELEPHANTS
Beautiful circus drama, but its romance is for discerning adults.
Should You Watch It?
This is a four-star film with real emotional power. Its circus setting, suspenseful danger, excellent performances, and concern for abused people and animals give it considerable merit. Jacob’s desire to protect Marlene and Rosie from August’s violent temper provides a moral center, even as the story makes troubling choices.
The central romance is the problem. Marlene is married, and the film presents Jacob’s growing desire for her sympathetically, despite the adultery involved. The content guide also notes strong violence, sexual immorality, foul language, lewd material, alcohol abuse, and smoking.
Adults who can weigh those conflicts carefully may find much to admire. Families with children or young teens should choose something else. For discerning adults, this is WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESIn 1931, veterinary student Jacob loses his parents in an automobile accident and discovers that his father’s debts have left him broke. He leaves Cornell University and boards a train, eventually finding work as the veterinarian for a traveling circus.
The circus belongs to August, a charismatic German immigrant with a terrible temper. Jacob is drawn to Marlene, August’s beautiful younger wife, and soon finds himself trying to protect both her and an abused elephant named Rosie.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars means this is a beautifully produced and compelling romantic drama. The movie is entertaining and suspenseful, with excellent performances throughout the cast.
Hal Holbrook gives the opening and closing scenes considerable heart and strong positive feeling. The film also has enough story and suspense to interest both men and women, rather than functioning only as a romance for one audience.
The Worldview
The film presents a mixed worldview. Its central romance supports adultery because Jacob falls in love with a married woman whose husband is mean, violent, and sometimes charming. The movie also includes moral elements in Jacob’s desire to protect people and animals from August’s violent rage.
The ending strongly supports family, marriage, and having children. The story also contains Christian themes of forgiveness and repentance, positive references to God, and positive Pro-American, patriotic content. Yet those affirmations exist alongside seedy circus values, sexual immorality, violence, and a pagan moral framework.
The film recognizes that protecting the vulnerable matters, but it does not handle marriage faithfully. Scripture says, “Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife” (Genesis 2:24).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Strong mixed pagan worldview with Romantic elements involving adultery with the beautiful wife of a mean man with a terrible temper who is a murderer and some moral elements supporting stopping said villain and, eventually, having a positive family life with the woman, including a couple positive references to God, plus some positive Pro-American, patriotic content and some Christian themes of forgiveness and repentance; 13 obscenities and two GD profanities, plus man gets sick and vomits; some strong intense violence and light violence includes threats, implied beating of elephant, man stabs elephant with a hook to move it that causes some minor bleeding, woman falls off elephant when it runs off, man has to shoot dying horse but not shown, thugs beat up protagonist, attempted strangulation of woman, police raid speakeasy, circus animals let loose, lion and tiger attack as circus audience flees, and circus owner is known for tossing unwanted people off his circus train when the train’s traveling at full speed; strong sexual immorality but not graphically depicted includes adulterous kissing and man runs off with another man’s wife to protect her after the husband decides to beat him up or kill him and it’s implied they fornicate, plus men watch striptease act at travelling circus and some lewd comments; two striptease women in skimpy outfits that barely cover their breasts; alcohol use, drunkenness and elderly man working as a circus roustabout is an alcoholic who drinks bad whiskey and eventually suffers for it; smoking; and, lying, animal abuse, man has violent temper, jealousy, exaggeration, tattoos, and seedy circus values.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
Jacob wants to protect Marlene and Rosie from August’s violence. When is protecting someone a responsibility, and how can protection remain truthful and wise?
Proverbs 31:8–9 · Psalm 82:3–4The film treats Jacob and Marlene’s attraction sympathetically even though she is married. What does Scripture say marriage requires, and how can desire be brought under faithfulness?
Exodus 20:14 · Hebrews 13:4August’s abuse harms both people and animals. What responsibilities does God give human beings toward those under their care?
Proverbs 12:10 · Colossians 3:19The story includes themes of forgiveness and repentance. How are forgiveness and repentance related, and why do both matter?
Luke 17:3–4 · 2 Corinthians 7:10The Final Word
This is a compelling, excellently acted drama with genuine moral concerns and serious content conflicts. Adults who can approach its adultery, violence, and other concerns with discernment may find the journey worthwhile. For children and young teens, choose another film. WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY.