Skip to content
Give
← All Reviews
MOVIE REVIEW

SHERMAN’S WAY

Taking life as it comes, with grown-up content.

2009NR97 minutesIFC FilmsComedy
Worth the trip — adults only.
ENTERTAINMENT QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 Poignant humor and strong performances.
FAMILY CONTENT Caution −2 on the +4 to −4 scale Caution for discerning adults; not for children or young teens.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Heavy
Violence Light
Sex Light
Nudity Moderate
BEST FOR Adults who appreciate quirky independent comedies.
NOT FOR Children, young teens, or viewers avoiding strong language, nudity, and drunkenness.
CONTENT IN ONE LINE Romantic and humanist ideas, excessive foul language, brief nudity, and alcohol use resulting in drunkenness.
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

Should You Watch It?

SHERMAN’S WAY is a small, quirky comedy with a well-written script, excellent acting, fine camerawork, and many enjoyable moments. Its central friendship gives the film a winsome quality as two very different men learn to face their choices, past failures, and uncertain futures.

But the movie’s strengths come with serious costs. Its Romantic worldview encourages living life to the fullest while looking inward for answers. The film also includes excessive foul language, brief nudity, and a drunken episode with a hangover.

This is worthwhile for discerning adults who can engage its ideas and content thoughtfully. It is not suitable for children or young teens. The practical answer: WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY.

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Sherman Black is a young, uptight New York lawyer who plans everything and travels to Napa Valley for a summer internship. There, circumstances throw him together with Palmer, a middle-aged, unsuccessful alpine ski bum who cannot plan beyond the next few minutes.

As the two men navigate an unexpected journey with help from several quirky characters, Sherman must learn that plans do not always unfold as expected. Palmer, meanwhile, must decide whether his past failures will define the rest of his life.

Is It Any Good?

Three stars means SHERMAN’S WAY is genuinely enjoyable but significantly flawed. As an independent production, it has surprisingly good elements: a well-written script, excellent acting, fine camerawork, and poignant humor.

The film also contains redemptive moments, especially Palmer’s awkward attempt to reconcile with his estranged son. Those strengths are ultimately weakened by the movie’s worldview, excessive foul language, brief nudity, and alcohol use resulting in drunkenness.

The Worldview

The film presents a strong Romantic worldview. Its characters are encouraged to live life to the fullest, embrace the present, and accept that carefully made plans may fail. Some of that emphasis can encourage courage and flexibility, but the movie also includes light humanist elements, with characters looking to themselves to solve problems and make life-altering decisions.

That self-reliance ultimately overshadows some of the film’s redemptive moral elements. Palmer’s effort to reconcile with his estranged son points toward responsibility, humility, and restoration. His past failures do not have to determine his future. Yet the film locates its answers primarily in personal choice and inward change rather than in God.

The movie’s central longing is to move beyond failure and receive the present as an opportunity for change. Scripture likewise calls people to take responsibility for their own lives: “For each will have to bear his own load” (Galatians 6:5).

Movieguide® worldview codes: RoRo, H, C, B, LLL, V, S, NN, AA, D, M — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.

Content Summary

Strong Romantic worldview where characters are encouraged to live life to the fullest, with humanist elements where characters look to themselves to solve problems and make life-altering decisions, that ultimately overshadow some redemptive, moral elements such as a man tries to reconcile with his estranged son; 40 obscenities and seven profanities, plus man unintentionally breaks wind because he ate spicy food; brief fistfight and man crashes on a pair of skis; brief kiss between girl and boy, girl kisses boy briefly and vice versa in another scene, some brief sexual material including reference made to porn and reference made to a rendezvous between three people; naked painting of woman on motorcycle tank partially shown, upper male nudity, rear male nudity and rear female nudity when characters go skinny dipping; depicted alcohol use when characters have wine with dinner a couple of times, characters drink bottles of beer here and there throughout movie, man gives his cat a cup of beer to drink, and character gets drunk and has a hangover the next day; man smokes a cigar in one scene; and, characters are made to believe they are stealing and they go through with it, even though it turns out to be a joke, girl cheats on her boyfriend, negative parental figure who has resigned himself to being a failure and refuses to try to finish or accomplish anything although this changes by the end of the movie, and man relies on himself and his own planning to accomplish his goals.

Talk About It

Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.

01

Sherman plans everything, yet life repeatedly disrupts his plans. How can you prepare wisely while still trusting God with the outcome?

Proverbs 16:9 · James 4:13–15
02

Palmer believes his past failures define him. What is the difference between taking responsibility for past choices and believing you can never change?

2 Corinthians 5:17 · Philippians 3:13–14
03

Palmer tries to reconcile with his estranged son. What makes an apology or attempt at reconciliation sincere?

Matthew 5:23–24 · Colossians 3:12–13

The Final Word

SHERMAN’S WAY offers poignant humor, excellent acting, and a winsome story about responsibility and second chances. Its worldview and mature content require discernment. For adults who can engage those concerns thoughtfully, WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY. For a family-friendly choice, see.

THE VERDICT Worth the trip — adults only.
Planning family movie night instead? Start with this week’s family-friendly picks →

More Movies Like This

Browse All Reviews →

Family-Friendly Alternatives