Skip to content
Give
← All Reviews
TV MOVIE REVIEW

GUARDING STARS

A pretend relationship, a Montana Christmas, and a bodyguard who never expected to fall in love.

2026TV-14110 minutesNetflixRomantic Comedy
WORTH THE WATCH - Adults Only.
ENTERTAINMENT QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 A delightfully predictable Christmas romance with plenty of action and adventure.
FAMILY CONTENT Discernment −1 on the +4 to −4 scale Frequent strong language, sexual innuendo, and action violence make this one less suitable for younger viewers.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Moderate
Violence Moderate
Sex Light
Nudity Light
BEST FOR Adults who enjoy a traditional Christmas romantic comedy with humor, family themes, and a dose of action.
NOT FOR Children, teens or families looking for a gentle, low-conflict Christmas movie.
CONTENT IN ONE LINE Light alcohol, some language, and action violence including physical confrontations, an attempted bombing, kidnapping, death threats, and a shooting, plus a satisfying and meaningful ending
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

Should You Watch It?

Yes, but know what you're getting into. If you enjoy a traditional Christmas romantic comedy, this movie delivers just about everything you could want, with a little extra action thrown in. The chemistry between the leads, beautiful Montana scenery, humorous moments, and heartwarming family storyline make this an entertaining holiday watch.

The romance follows a familiar, predictable path, but the performances and genuine emotional moments make it easy to enjoy. There is more depth here than you might expect, particularly in the storylines surrounding grief, forgiveness, and the importance of family. Hannah's journey from keeping everyone at a distance to finding a place that feels welcoming and loved becomes especially gratifying.

However, this isn't your typical gentle Christmas romance. Considerable action and violence appear throughout, including gunfire, physical fights, a kidnapping, and a shooting. Language and sexual innuendo are also present. If you look for a clean, low-conflict holiday movie, this isn't it. But if you enjoy a fun, sentimental Christmas romance with an adventurous twist, grown-ups find plenty to enjoy here.

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Hannah Brooks is a highly trained bodyguard assigned to protect Jack Stapleton, a famous actor being stalked by a dangerous stalker. When Jack needs to spend Christmas with his family at their Montana ranch without worrying them about the potential threat, he comes up with an unusual solution:

Hannah will pretend to be his girlfriend. Hannah finds discomfort with the arrangement, especially when it means trading her carefully planned security detail for family Christmas traditions, unpredictable horses, and a house full of people who want to get close to her. As the two spend more time together, their pretend relationship starts to feel a little less pretend.

Is It Any Good?

Three stars for a well-made romantic comedy with strong performances, convincing dialogue, and excellent cinematography. The Montana scenery provides a beautiful backdrop, and the soundtrack fits the story particularly well. The pacing remains strong, balancing romance, humor, family drama, and action without losing direction.

Leighton Meester delivers a particularly good job portraying Hannah's guarded personality. She stays intentionally difficult to like at first, and watching her gradually soften becomes an important part of the story. The chemistry between the leads works well, and the supporting family characters add plenty of warmth and humor.

The storyline stays fairly predictable, following a familiar romantic-comedy formula, and some action sequences require a generous suspension of disbelief. Still, the movie knows what it wants to be and delivers an entertaining, well-executed holiday romance with a satisfying, emotional ending.

The Worldview

A moral worldview anchors the movie. At its heart, the story explores family, grief, forgiveness, and the courage to let people in. Past loss and trauma leave Hannah guarded and uneasy with emotional connection. Jack distances himself from his family since his brother's death, and unresolved guilt and resentment now divide him from his younger brother.

The movie makes an important point about forgiveness and urges us not to let past hurts separate us from the people we love. Hannah shares strong wisdom: you can't get time back, but you can make more of the time ahead. Her words remind viewers that time with family is precious, and no one should take it for granted.

Honesty runs throughout the story as another strong theme. The characters learn to tell the truth to themselves and others and recognize when they must come clean about their lies. The movie also echoes a familiar Biblical principle: when we run from our problems, they don't go away, and our flight often causes even more hurt along the way.

Many of these themes reflect a Biblical view of forgiveness, reconciliation, family, sacrifice, and love. Still, it doesn't center on faith. Christmas provides the setting, and one line briefly mentions Jesus, but the story focuses on romantic love and family ties rather than the significance of Christ's birth.

Movieguide® worldview codes: B, LL, VV, S, N, A, MM — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements

Strong moral worldview with Biblical themes of family, forgiveness, honesty, teamwork, service, sacrifice, and love, as the absent brother returns home, the family unites to support one another through a hard time, two brothers find forgiveness and reconciliation after years of resentment, the heroine devotes her life to others at the cost of her own safety and welfare, and the male lead risks his own wellbeing to protect her

Foul Language

Frequent foul language with eight light profanities (variations of OMG), five “h” words, three “bad*ss,” two “a” words, a few “s,” “d,” and “crap” obscenities, two unfinished “what the” exclamations, a crude label for Kennedy Monroe’s followers as “the Monroe Hos,” and a reference to flatulence in a silly song

Violence

Strong action violence with an attempted bomb attack, gunfire, threats against the main characters, physical confrontations, a chokehold, and an abduction, plus a gunshot wound to the shoulder of a character who protects another, a horseback pursuit, a car chase, and a fall from a moving vehicle

Sex

No sex scenes, but some sexual innuendo and suggestive dialogue, with references to “sexy,” romantic kisses, and a passionate kiss at a rodeo

Nudity

Partial nudity when a woman lifts her shirt to expose her midriff

Alcohol Use

Light alcohol use, as the family drinks wine at dinner and the male lead recalls that he and his brother “had a few drinks” during a past incident

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse

No smoking or drugs;

Miscellaneous Immorality

The stalkers lie, deceive, kidnap, and act out of revenge, greed, and envy, and the former romantic partners exchange several accusatory and disrespectful words.

Talk About It

Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.

01

Jack and his brother carry resentment and hurt for years before finally talking honestly about what happened. Why is it sometimes difficult to forgive someone, even when you love them? What does the Bible teach us about forgiveness? Colossians 3:13.

02

Jack realizes that he has missed important moments with his family because he has kept his distance. Why is it important to make time for the people we love? Are there ways we sometimes allow other things to become more important? Ephesians 5:15–16.

03

Hannah has learned to protect herself by keeping people at a distance. As she spends time with Jack's family, she begins to experience the comfort of being loved and welcomed. Why do you think it's sometimes difficult to let others get close? How can we show others that they are welcome and loved? Romans 12:10.

04

Throughout the movie, characters demonstrate their love through their actions, whether protecting someone, offering forgiveness, or simply showing up when they're needed. How does the Bible describe genuine love? What are some practical ways we can demonstrate that kind of love to our family and friends? 1 Corinthians 13:4–7.

The Final Word

GUARDING STARS is an entertaining Christmas romantic comedy with beautiful scenery, strong performances, plenty of humor, and a genuinely heartwarming story. Its familiar romance is balanced by meaningful themes of forgiveness, family, and learning to let others in. However, the considerable action, violence, language, and sexual innuendo are worth considering before watching. If you enjoy a traditional holiday romance with a little extra adventure, this is a fun pick for adults only.

THE VERDICT WORTH THE WATCH - Adults Only.
Planning family movie night instead? Start with this week’s family-friendly picks →

More Movies Like This

Browse All Reviews →

Family-Friendly Alternatives