Before actress Jen Lilley got the call for JIMMY, she had reached a surprising place: she could be content even if she never acted again.
“You can either let it harden you or you can let it soften you,” Lilley told “Got It From My Momma” podcast host Jennifer Vickery Smith, reflecting on how people respond when hard times hit.
For Lilley, that difficult stretch brought a deeper dependence on God, not a tidy explanation for every disappointment. In the newly released interview, she described the morning she learned she would play Gloria Stewart, actor Jimmy Stewart’s wife, as the beginning of a new chapter.
During her prayer time that morning, the actress recalled picturing a boat reaching shore and sensing God telling her she had made it to the other side of a painful season. She said she cried, grateful for how near He had been through it.
Then came the phone call, about 30 minutes later, offering her the role. Lilley said she had already told God she did not want to leave that season behind unless He went with her.
That opportunity now brings her to theaters as Gloria in JIMMY. The movie opens Nov. 6 and follows Stewart, played by actor KJ Apa, through his wartime service and return to the screen in IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE.
Related: Here’s Why This Singer Wanted to Be Part of the Jimmy Stewart Biopic
Lilley initially wondered about the casting because she did not share Gloria’s height or appearance. But she recalled director Aaron Burns emphasizing something else. Gloria was a mother whose steady presence mattered more than a physical match.
“I was honored that that’s what they saw in me to bring to the screen,” Lilley said.
Motherhood has also changed which opportunities she accepts. The mom of four described reaching a crossroads with her music, when a chance to pursue the singing career she had dreamed about as a child collided with the demands of a full touring schedule.
She chose not to take that path, prioritizing her marriage and children. That did not mean she suddenly stopped loving music — or that the decision stopped stinging.
“Yeah, it was a hard decision,” Lilley said, explaining that hearing music in a record label’s sound system can still make her want to cry because she loves it so much.
Her account of making family life work was practical, too: her husband worked nights, she covered evenings, and travel sometimes required his vacation time or help from their parents. No effortless balancing act there.
Lilley has kept finding other ways to put her gifts to work. Her charity page describes Christmas Is Not Cancelled, a pandemic-era initiative that grew into drives supplying toys and school supplies to children and families in foster care.
She also said she wrote books during her difficult season. Her devotional, Wake Up Your Faith: 365 Daily Encounters with Jesus, offers Scripture-centered reflections and practical steps, according to publisher BroadStreet Publishing.
And she is not finished dreaming. Lilley talked about wanting to do more movies and trying a sitcom, while encouraging other women not to dismiss their own gifts.
“There’s never been another you. There’s never been another me,” she said.
Questions or comments? Please write to us here.