ARTHUR
A lavish, funny remake that loses its moral center.
Should You Watch It?
ARTHUR has real strengths. Its sets, costumes, and props are extravagant, and Russell Brand finds a few genuinely funny moments as the ridiculous billionaire playboy. The story also points toward love, integrity, responsibility, sobriety, and moral redemption.
But the remake is much crasser than the 1981 film, and its redemptive story is not as clearly told. Arthur’s alcohol problem receives heavy attention, while his broader lack of moral values receives less. The film also lacks spiritual redemption and includes sexual content, vulgarity, partial nudity, and mixed worldview elements.
If you are an adult who wants to watch this comedy, wait for home, where you can control the experience and discuss its ideas; do not choose it for children or young teens.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESArthur Buck is a wealthy, alcoholic playboy whose extravagant lifestyle repeatedly embarrasses his mother and his family’s company. When his mother gives him a choice between marrying for money or losing his fortune, Arthur reluctantly accepts the arrangement.
Then he meets Naomi, an aspiring children’s book author from Queens. As Arthur falls in love with her, his nanny Hobson tries to help him face his drinking, his selfishness, and the damage caused by his family relationships.
Is It Any Good?
Three stars means ARTHUR is entertaining and well made, but falls short of the earlier film and a truly strong redemptive story.
The production quality is excellent, with considerable attention to detail in the extravagant sets, costumes, and props. Russell Brand’s ridiculous humor reaches a few high points that are truly funny. However, there are too many crass moments, and Brand lacks the charm and sophistication Dudley Moore brought to the role.
The story is also not told as well as it was in the original. Its focus on alcohol weakens the emotional force of Arthur’s relationship with Hobson, and Arthur’s sudden change leaves a large story gap.
The Worldview
ARTHUR presents a light Christian or redemptive moral outlook about overcoming excess and alcoholism, but it is marred by strong pagan and light romantic elements. The film argues that wealth cannot provide what love provides, and it portrays Arthur moving toward responsibility, sobriety, integrity, and respect. It also offers a positive message against alcohol and dysfunctional family relationships.
At the same time, the story lacks spiritual redemption. Arthur is helped by Hobson, his driver, Alcoholics Anonymous, and Naomi, but the film does not ground his recovery in God. Its moral code is ultimately close to “eat, drink and be merry for tomorrow you die,” even as it criticizes Arthur’s debauched lifestyle. Hobson believes Arthur can make the right decisions, but she is not presented as a good moral role model herself.
The film’s central longing is for love and a healthier family bond. Scripture gives that longing a deeper foundation: “Let all that you do be done in love” (1 Corinthians 16:14).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Light Christian or redemptive, moral worldview about overcoming excess and alcoholism, marred by strong pagan and light Romantic elements, plus when man is accidentally hit by nail gun, the title character jokes, “Nails made a hero out of Jesus so you could go with that"; two obscenities, no profanities and some comical vulgarities like “winky”; some comical violence with minor bleeding includes title character accidentally shoots another character with a nail gun, riot started, title character almost has his tongue sawed off by future father-in-law; light sexual content includes seduction scene with allusion to sex but man shuns woman in lingerie’s advances, kissing and references to a sex video; partial nudity as title character is seen running in nothing but his underwear at one point and upper male nudity and woman in lingerie in seduction scene; strong alcohol use as title character portrays an alcoholic who, however, eventually goes to AA and becomes sober; no smoking but a comical drug references when recovering alcoholic mentions to some schoolchildren about his “candy addiction” and some of the children ask him if it was meth, crack or booze; and, dysfunctional family portrayed as main character’s father is deceased and mother values money over her son, son shows no respect, son is raised by the “hired help,” and a dying character says they’ll probably end up looking up from Hell at another character instead of looking down on him from Heaven.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
Arthur has money but lacks love, integrity, and responsibility. What does the film suggest wealth cannot provide, and what does Scripture say is truly valuable?
Matthew 6:19–21 · 1 Corinthians 13:3Arthur’s drinking damages his relationships and his life. Why is admitting a problem an important part of change?
Proverbs 28:13 · James 5:16Hobson helps raise Arthur after his father’s death, while Arthur’s mother values money over her son. What responsibilities do parents and families have toward one another?
Ephesians 6:4 · 1 Timothy 5:8Arthur faces a choice between money and love. How should love shape the decisions we make?
1 Corinthians 16:14 · Philippians 2:3–4The Final Word
ARTHUR is lavish, occasionally very funny, and pointed toward moral recovery. But its crassness, mixed content, and incomplete redemption make it better suited to discerning adults at home than to a theater trip with the family. Our answer is WAIT FOR HOME — ADULTS ONLY. For a different family movie night, see.