THE CLOSER YOU GET
A winsome Irish comedy best kept for discerning adults at home.
Should You Watch It?
THE CLOSER YOU GET has winsome points. Its central ideas—that the grass is not greener on the other side and that lust can make us overlook love—have genuine moral value. The mostly unknown cast is entertaining, and the film offers some positive references to Christianity and God.
But getting there requires much sexual discussion, broken relationships, and off-screen fornication. The content section also notes 17 obscenities, 11 mumbled profanities, pornography, alcohol, smoking, and hedonism. The priest mixes good Christian advice with bad advice and a salacious analogy about relationships.
The film is also uneven. Its first-time director makes a valiant effort, but the story often drifts. Watch it only at home, and only if you are an adult or an older teenager whose family has judged the content appropriate.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESIn a beautiful, tiny, windswept community in Ireland, the local men are discouraged by the lack of marriage and the departure of young people for America, England, and Ireland’s larger cities.
After a movie-night mishap leaves them smitten with an image of American beauty, the men place an advertisement in a Miami newspaper inviting American women to their remote village for the annual dance. Kieran, a local butcher, leads the effort to bring romance to Donagal.
Is It Any Good?
Two stars means this is a modestly entertaining comedy with clear weaknesses. The action by mainly unknown actors is mostly entertaining, and first-time director Aileen Ritchie makes a valiant effort with the material.
The film does not sustain a sense of jeopardy, however. Many moments simply drift, weakening the story’s momentum. The same subject matter was handled better—and much more cleanly and morally—in Sense and Sensibility.
The Worldview
THE CLOSER YOU GET presents a very slight moral worldview. It condemns divorce and affirms that the grass is not greener elsewhere, while also showing how people can overlook love because of lust. Those are morally useful observations.
The film’s sexual preoccupation and hedonism complicate those points. Father Hubert Malone is especially difficult to assess. He offers some good Christian advice and refers to God, but he also gives a salacious analogy about relationships, appears to condone a broken relationship and a quick rematch, and watches 10 after stopping its showing.
The movie includes both positive references to Christianity and some denigration of Christianity. Its moral vision is therefore mixed: it recognizes that selfish desire damages relationships, but it does not consistently present biblical wisdom about love, sexuality, or marriage. Scripture says, “Let marriage be held in honor among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled” (Hebrews 13:4).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Very, very slight moral worldview that condemns divorce, plus some positive references to Christianity as well as some denigration of Christianity, lots of hedonism & a preoccupation with sex; 17 obscenities (many mumbled in an Irish dialect) & 11 mostly “Oh G*d” mumbled profanities; one slugging of a person in the nose & some lightweight scuffling; much discussion about sex, kissing, foreplay (clothed) & scenes before & after fornication (clothed); brief picture of a PLAYBOY & another pornographic magazine; alcohol use; smoking; and, a priest gives a very salacious analogy to sex & watches Bo Derek in the movie 10, but also gives good & lackluster advice.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The men pursue an imagined kind of romance after seeing an idealized image of beauty. How can desire distort the way we see the people already in our lives?
James 1:14–15 · Philippians 4:8The film presents both good and bad advice from a priest. How should Christians test advice, even when it comes from a religious leader?
Acts 17:11 · 1 Thessalonians 5:21The story condemns divorce while also involving broken relationships and quick romantic changes. What does Scripture call marriage to be, and how should love show faithfulness?
Matthew 19:4–6 · 1 Corinthians 13:4–7The characters are tempted to believe that fulfillment lies somewhere else. What does contentment look like when your circumstances feel disappointing?
Philippians 4:11–13 · Hebrews 13:5The Final Word
THE CLOSER YOU GET has a winsome moral premise and some entertaining performances, but its sexual material, profanity, and mixed relationship advice make it unsuitable for children and young teens. Its uneven storytelling also makes home viewing the wiser choice for discerning adults and older teenagers. WAIT FOR HOME — ADULTS ONLY. For a cleaner alternative, see.