Skip to content
Give
← All Reviews
MOVIE REVIEW

THE BROKEN HEARTS CLUB

An R-rated romance the review finds morally offensive and unsuitable.

2000R95 minutesSony Pictures ClassicsHomosexual Romantic Comedy
Skip it.
ENTERTAINMENT QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 A sympathetic but deeply objectionable romantic comedy.
FAMILY CONTENT Abhorrent −4 on the +4 to −4 scale Abhorrent; not recommended for any viewer.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Heavy
Violence None
Sex Moderate
Nudity Light
NOT FOR Families, children, young adults seeking wholesome entertainment, or viewers who reject the film’s sexual and moral worldview.
CONTENT IN ONE LINE Strong foul language, profanity misusing Jesus Christ’s name, homosexual behavior and sexual references, drug use resulting in an overdose, and a worldview the source finds offensive.
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

Should You Watch It?

The source gives this movie three stars for entertainment quality, but its −4 Family Content rating makes the practical decision clear. The film presents a group of practicing homosexual men and argues for long-term intimate relationships instead of promiscuity. It avoids graphic sexual images and explicit nudity, but it still attempts to mainstream homosexual behavior.

The content includes 59 mostly strong obscenities, four strong profanities mentioning Jesus Christ, implied homosexual sex, marijuana and other drug use, and a subplot involving sperm donation so that a lesbian couple can have a baby. The review also finds the relationships to be caricatures of heterosexual romance and morally offensive.

For your family or your own viewing choices, SKIP IT.

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Dennis, a 28-year-old West Hollywood photographer, has grown tired of the promiscuous lifestyle of his close friends. When he meets Kevin, a young man just beginning to experiment with homosexuality, Dennis tries to mentor him and protect him from sexual predators in the community.

The story follows their relationships, friendships, and attempts to find romance rather than sexual promiscuity.

Is It Any Good?

Three stars mean the source sees real entertainment value in the film, though the review offers few specific craft observations. It is described as a romantic comedy with a “universal” romantic premise and a focus on long-term relationships rather than sex.

The movie also avoids graphic sexual images and explicit nudity. However, the source criticizes its romantic relationships as parodies of familiar heterosexual relationships and finds the film’s moral and sexual agenda deeply objectionable. ****

The Worldview

The film presents homosexual relationships as a normal part of romantic life and argues that lasting intimacy is preferable to promiscuity. The source credits it with rejecting wanton sex within its story, but says the movie still tries to mainstream homosexual behavior and treats it as a romantic alternative to God’s created order.

The review also argues that the film’s relationships imitate familiar heterosexual patterns rather than offering an authentic moral vision. Its subplot involving a lesbian couple and sperm donation further departs from the traditional family structure the source upholds. The movie’s use of strong profanity, including profanity mentioning Jesus Christ, adds to the offense for Christian viewers.

The source’s central theological answer is that human beings cannot rescue themselves through manmade rules or romantic relationships. As Romans says, “Who will rescue me from this body of death? Thanks be to God—through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Romans 7:24–25).

Movieguide® worldview codes: PaPaPa, HoHoHo, PCPCPC, AB, LLL, SS, N, A, DD, MM — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.

Content Summary

Homosexual pagan worldview that tries to mainstream the sexual immorality of homosexual lust, a politically correct, ultimately leftist agenda, plus a snide comment against the National Rifle Association & Promise Keepers, a Christian group for men; 59 mostly strong obscenities, 7 mild profanities & 4 strong profanities mentioning Jesus Christ, plus some crude talk about homosexuality; no violence; depicted homosexual kissing, implied homosexual sodomy, implied homosexual promiscuity, & verbal references to homosexual sex, some of them crude; brief upper male nudity; alcohol use; smoking, marijuana smoking & other depicted drug use, which results in an overdose; and, lying, jealousy, betrayal, & lesbian woman’s homosexual brother agrees to donate his sperm so that her girlfriend can have their baby.

Talk About It

Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.

01

The film prefers long-term relationships to promiscuity. What does Scripture say love, faithfulness, and sexual holiness should look like?

1 Corinthians 13:4–7 · 1 Thessalonians 4:3–5
02

The story raises the question of whether people can keep moral rules through their own strength. Why does Scripture point us to Christ rather than self-reliance?

Romans 7:24–25 · Romans 8:1–4
03

The movie presents its sexual worldview as something everyone should accept. How should Christians respond when a culture calls something “universal” that conflicts with biblical teaching?

Romans 12:2 · Acts 17:11

The Final Word

The film has some entertainment value and rejects promiscuity within its story, but it also promotes a sexual worldview the source finds immoral and offensive. With strong language, drug use, sexual content, and a −4 Family Content rating, SKIP IT. For alternatives, see.

THE VERDICT Skip it.
Planning family movie night instead? Start with this week’s family-friendly picks →

More Movies Like This

Browse All Reviews →