TELLING LIES IN AMERICA
A slow, morally corrupt drama about lies, acceptance, and compromise.
Should You Watch It?
TELLING LIES IN AMERICA has a personal, nostalgic setting and a potentially worthwhile question: what will someone sacrifice for acceptance and citizenship? But the film’s treatment of that question is slow, dull, and morally confused.
The story follows a young immigrant drawn toward a dishonest radio personality. Instead of clearly condemning the boy’s choices, the movie implies that his immorality is acceptable and even suggests that the American legal system can be manipulated to accommodate personal desires. Its two-star entertainment quality does not offset that worldview.
You should skip this movie, especially for family viewing.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESIn early-1960s Cleveland, Hungarian immigrant Karchy Jonas is a poor, unpopular high school senior seeking acceptance from his peers and naturalization for himself and his father.
Karchy’s gift for lying attracts Billy Magic, a slick local radio disc jockey who hires him to run errands. As Karchy becomes more involved with Billy’s world, he must face questions about friendship, honesty, and the cost of becoming accepted as an American.
Is It Any Good?
Two stars means the film has a few worthwhile touches but does not come together as satisfying entertainment. The art direction is impressive, and the period music gives the early-1960s setting credibility.
The other production elements are only passable. Kevin Bacon does well with a fairly one-dimensional character, while Brad Renfro again plays a bad boy without showing much growth. The movie’s slow-moving, dull approach ultimately overwhelms its personal and heartfelt qualities.
The Worldview
The film presents a strong humanist worldview centered on cheating and telling lies, with some Christian elements. Karchy is ashamed of his poor background and repeatedly lies to make himself appear better. He is drawn to slick hucksters, and the story ultimately treats his immorality as acceptable rather than presenting truthfulness and repentance as clear moral goods.
The movie also questions a familiar American moral lesson by suggesting that the story of George Washington and the cherry tree is “a bunch of malarkey.” It appears to argue that if America was founded by a liar, the legal system can be manipulated to accommodate anyone’s desires. That view departs sharply from the biblical call to honesty, even though the film includes Christian references and settings.
Karchy’s longing for love, acceptance, and a place in America points to a real human need. But Scripture does not answer that need with self-invention or deception: “Therefore, having put away falsehood, let each one of you speak the truth with his neighbor” (Ephesians 4:25).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Strong humanist worldview of cheating & telling lies with some Christian elements; 20 obscenities & 15 profanities; mild violence such as bullying & fist-fighting; implied fornication with a prostitute, another instance of implied fornication & some sexual talk; upper male nudity & women in underwear; alcohol use & underage drinking; smoking; and, miscellaneous immorality including many instances of lying, pretending to be priest in confessional, vandalism, & urination.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
Karchy lies to gain acceptance and improve his circumstances. Why can deception seem attractive, and what does God call us to do instead?
Ephesians 4:25 · Proverbs 12:22The film connects citizenship and belonging with personal identity. Where should Christians find their deepest sense of belonging?
Philippians 3:20 · 1 Peter 2:9What is the difference between feeling sorry for wrongdoing and genuinely turning from it?
2 Corinthians 7:10 · Proverbs 28:13How should Christians respond when a story treats immoral choices as acceptable?
Isaiah 5:20 · Romans 12:2The Final Word
TELLING LIES IN AMERICA has an appealing period setting and a few credible performances, but it is slow, dull, and morally corrupt. Its treatment of lying and cheating offers no sound guide for your family. Our answer is SKIP IT. For better options, see.