Mom and Dad still outrank friends, social media and AI as sources teens feel comfortable approaching for advice about who they are, according to new Barna research.
“Our job is to make sure a trusted adult, not an algorithm, is in that space,” said Richard Hamilton, a youth pastor at Castle Hills Christian Church, in Barna’s Oct. 26 report.
The findings offer parents some encouragement: 84% of US teens say they would feel comfortable seeking identity advice from their mother, and 78% say the same about their father. Friends follow at 75%, while adult mentors and teachers each register 67%.
These numbers describe whom teenagers feel comfortable asking, not a record of whom they actually consult. Barna surveyed 1,500 US teens ages 13–18 in February 2026 for research produced with Christ In Youth.
Faith matters in those conversations, too. Among all teens surveyed, 68% feel comfortable getting advice from Jesus and 66% from the Bible, compared with 56% for a pastor and 51% for a youth pastor.
The backdrop is more complicated than a teenager deciding which adult has the best answer. In a June report from the same research, Barna found that 70% feel pressure to resolve who they really are, while 72% feel pressure around what is true or worth believing.
For Christian families, that leaves plenty of room for conversations about identity, purpose and what Scripture teaches. Teens can feel pressure to figure life out even when they appear confident on the outside.
Related: Gen Z Wants ‘Faith-Based’ Movies and TV—Here’s What We Know
Among the teens Barna calls Faith-Activated, Jesus and the Bible each reach 78%, nearly matching mothers at 80%. The designation measures engagement across six areas, including spiritual practices, service and belonging; teens qualify by meeting Barna’s activation threshold in at least five.
But strong faith engagement does not mean these teenagers automatically keep digital advice at arm’s length. The same group also expresses greater trust in AI than teens overall.
Nearly half of Faith-Activated teens, 49%, strongly agree that they trust technology and AI to provide helpful information, compared with 29% of all teens. And 46% strongly agree that AI feels like a safe place for questions they would not ask aloud, versus 28% overall.
Another 45% strongly agree they would rather ask a digital tool than a person when uncertain, compared with 26% of all teens. Those answers come from separate questions about technology, not the identity-advice ranking.
Parents need not mistake those findings for proof that AI has replaced them. AI draws 35% in the identity-advice question, well below mothers and fathers, but its appeal as a private place for uncomfortable questions deserves attention.
Being available matters, and parents need support themselves. In separate guidance published in September 2025, Barna encouraged churches to offer parenting workshops, strengthen listening skills and create places where parents can share struggles, pray together and learn from experts.
The October report makes a similar case for partnership: youth ministries can help parents disciple their teenagers at home instead of treating parental influence as competition. The survey does not prove that any particular parenting approach causes greater trust.
“Students are listening more than it seems,” youth ministry leader Deborah Spooner said in the report.
For parents wondering whether their voice still carries, that is a reason to keep the conversation open. The next hard question may be an opportunity to listen before rushing in with an answer.
Read Next: What You Really Need to Know About Gen Z’s Faith
Questions or comments? Please write to us here.
