The creators behind familiar family viewing are finding new buyers at Disney and Netflix, while YouTube is pressing some talent to keep its platform first.
“It’s a very good time to be in the creator business,” Adam Wescott, CEO of Home Game Studios, told The Hollywood Reporter earlier this week.
That opportunity comes with a dispute over how freely creators can expand. THR reported that YouTube has paired stronger brand-deal support with warnings about opportunities creators could lose if they shift their loyalties to competing platforms.
According to THR’s reporting, those potential losses include a place onstage at YouTube’s Brandcast advertising event and support for Emmy campaigns. The outlet also reported suggestions that creators might no longer qualify for YouTube Select, an advertising program for top creators, if they pursue rival-platform deals.
Some of those accounts come from unnamed creators and sources. They remain attributed allegations, not established findings about YouTube’s conduct or a confirmed change to the program’s eligibility rules.
“That was never their approach in the past,” Wescott told THR. He described the previous approach as supporting creators and reminding them why YouTube was their home.
YouTube’s leadership has publicly offered an advertising-based explanation for the commercial trade-offs. In a Sept. 23 Dow Jones report, available through Tiger Brokers, YouTube CEO Neal Mohan discussed how a creator’s distribution choices affect conversations with advertisers.
Related: Dude Perfect Scores Disney Collab, But Honoring God Always Comes First
“When you’re speaking to an advertiser, they have to have some understanding about where this content is available and when,” Mohan said.
For families, the business tussle has a recognizable face: Dude Perfect, who recently teamed up with Disney. Disney’s Oct. 15 partnership announcement said the sports-and-comedy group will make original content for its own channels inspired by Disney franchises and events, with select content also appearing on Disney+.
The arrangement also gives Disney access to selected existing short-form videos for Disney+, ESPN and its social platforms. Planned collaborations include Super Bowl LXI, the 50th anniversary of STAR WARS and AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY, illustrating how creator deals can stretch beyond a single streaming show.
Netflix has another concrete example in Mark Rober’s upcoming competition series SCHOOLED! Its March announcement describes teams of young innovators tackling science experiments in a gamified laboratory, with production by Rober’s CrunchLabs and Kimmelot.
That project shows what a streaming partner can offer beyond carrying existing videos: a new format built around a creator’s established appeal. THR reported that creators want financing for bigger ideas, while streamers want recognizable personalities who can produce programming quickly.
Not every creator sees traditional entertainment as the destination. Comedian and creator Lilly Singh discussed her return to sketch comedy in an Oct. 15 interview on YouTube’s official blog, describing the independence she values on the platform.
“On YouTube, there are no gatekeepers demanding I make my brain baby more palatable for the masses,” Singh said.
The choice need not mean abandoning YouTube altogether. THR reported that none of the creators or representatives it spoke with suggested a complete departure, even while exploring original projects elsewhere.
Parents can follow those projects without treating a familiar creator’s name as an automatic recommendation. A new platform or production partner can mean a different format, so checking the actual show remains more useful than assuming every project will resemble the videos a family already knows.
Read Next: Content Creator Quit YouTube After 12 Years in ‘Output Mode’
Questions or comments? Please write to us here.
