Skip to content
Give
← All Reviews
TV REVIEW

THE NAUGHTY NINE

A pretty Christmas package with a divisive message inside.

2023(Not yet rated)83 minutesDisney+/Walt Disney CompanyFamily/Adventure/Crime
Skip it.
ENTERTAINMENT QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 Polished, festive, and well-made.
FAMILY CONTENT Excessive −3 on the +4 to −4 scale Despite a last-minute moral, this one carries messages we can't recommend for your family.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language None
Violence Light
Sex Light
Nudity None
BEST FOR No one we can point to with a clear conscience.
NOT FOR Families looking for a warm, traditional Christmas story — this isn't it.
CONTENT IN ONE LINE A heavy woke agenda including a transgender child and a boy with two "gay dads," plus a whole cast built around lying, stealing, revenge, and disrespect until the very end.
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

Should You Watch It?

Here is our answer up front. THE NAUGHTY NINE is a good-looking piece of work — magical settings, outstanding costumes, festive music, and a story that clearly had potential. On craft alone, it's a capable film.

But Disney has once again chosen to serve a woke god at its audience's expense. The movie is inundated with a divisive, politically correct message: one child is transgender, another has two "gay dads," and the whole cast spends nearly the entire runtime lying, stealing, seeking revenge, and disrespecting everyone around them. The children do try to make things right at the end, which remits some of the offenses — but by then the characters are simply too naughty for you to care.

So our counsel is plain. If you're looking for a Christmas story that draws your family together in the traditional way, this one fragments rather than unites. Skip it, and reach for something that celebrates the season instead.

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Andy is a lying, manipulative, selfish middle-schooler who's indignant to discover he's landed on Santa's Naughty List — and that Christmas hasn't gone his way.

So he plots revenge. Andy recruits eight other Naughty List kids to fly to the North Pole and steal the wishlist toys they feel entitled to. He even talks his Nice List sister into joining the scheme. Their ragtag team dodges emergency landings and perilous puzzles on the way to Santa's Toy Shop. But somewhere along the road, Andy's conscience starts to catch up with him.

Is It Any Good?

Three stars, and here's what they buy. On the technical side, THE NAUGHTY NINE delivers. The settings are genuinely magical, the costumes are outstanding — one is even a small plot point — and the music is festive enough to carry a Christmas party sequence with real elves, complete with music and dancing.

The problem isn't the polish. It's that the film asks you to spend eighty-plus minutes with children who are unlikeable by design. Andy doesn't have his change of heart until the last possible moment, and the story is so saturated with its agenda that the warmth never arrives. The result is a well-crafted movie you won't want to sit through. Craft got the stars; the storytelling squandered them.

The Worldview

At its surface, THE NAUGHTY NINE gestures at a light morality play about doing the right thing. Santa tells the children to try to be good, and removes them from the Naughty List because they helped friends in trouble. There are even light references to Christmas.

But the season's true center is missing. There's no mention of the reason for the season — no Christ, and not even any "Christmas Spirit." What fills the gap is what the source calls a divisive, politically correct false ideology: the woke agenda. One child is transgender — a nine-year-old boy who dresses feminine, wears makeup, and calls another boy a "hottie." Another child has two homosexual "fathers." Around all of it swirls lying, deceit, stealing, revenge, greed, and dysfunctional family portrayals, with children serving as bad role models for most of the runtime.

The heart of the story is entitlement — children convinced they're owed the best toys and willing to steal to get them. That's a longing the gospel answers differently. The real gift of Christmas was never earned by the nice or seized by the naughty; it was given freely. "For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord" (Romans 6:23).

Movieguide® worldview codes: B, ABAB, PCPC, FRFR, HoHo, C, V, S, MMM — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.

Content Summary

(

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements

Light morality play about doing the right thing, plus Santa tells children to try to be good and removes them from the naughty list because they helped their friends who were in trouble, but the characters are very naughty until the end, also marred by politically correct false ideology/religion of woke ideology, a transgender child, and another youth has two gay dads, some light references to Christmas, but no mention of the reason for the season of Christmas or even Christmas Spirit

Foul Language

No obscenities or profanities, but a child calls other children suckers a few times

Violence

Emergency plane landing, snowmobile accidents, patrol men get into snowball accidents, and other slapstick comedy

Sex

9-year-old boy dresses feminine with makeup and calls another boy a “hottie,” plus another child has two homosexual “fathers”

Nudity

No nudity

Alcohol Use

No alcohol use

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse

No smoking or drugs;

Miscellaneous Immorality

Lying, deceit, stealing, revenge, greed, gambling, blackmail, bad role models, dysfunctional family portrayals.

Talk About It

Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.

01

Andy believes he's entitled to the best toys and is willing to steal to get them. Where does entitlement come from, and how does contentment work against it?

Philippians 4:11–12 · Hebrews 13:5
02

The children spend most of the story lying, deceiving, and taking revenge before trying to make things right at the end. Is a last-minute change of heart enough to undo real wrongs — and what does true repentance look like?

2 Corinthians 7:10 · Luke 19:8–9
03

The movie leaves out the reason for the season entirely. Why did Christmas begin, and what makes the real gift of that first Christmas different from anything on a wish list?

Luke 2:10–11 · John 3:16
04

Andy talks his "Nice List" sister into doing wrong. How do the people around us shape our choices, for good or ill, and how do we resist bad influence?

1 Corinthians 15:33 · Proverbs 13:20

The Final Word

Disney wrapped this one in beautiful costumes, magical sets, and festive music — real craft, no question. But it fills that pretty package with a divisive agenda and a cast of children too naughty to root for, and it forgets the reason for the season entirely. So our answer stands: skip it. For a Christmas movie that actually draws your family together, start with our latest family-friendly picks.

THE VERDICT Skip it.
Planning family movie night instead? Start with this week’s family-friendly picks →

More TV Shows Like This

Browse All Reviews →

Family-Friendly Alternatives